程序博客网 > 电子音乐软件下载

Grizzly和Netty以及Mina简单性能对比

来源：互联网 发布：电子音乐软件下载 编辑：程序博客网 时间：2024/04/30 04:08
最近在服务框架中尝试增加了Grizzly传输集成，简单测试后发现，TPS(每秒处理请求数)略低于Netty，略高于Mina，相差并不是很大，但TPS比Netty稳定很多(每秒方差小)，不会出现大幅波动，可以考虑备选。 

Mina为ApacheDirectory服务器的底层NIO框架：http://mina.apache.org 
Netty为JBoss的NIO框架：http://www.jboss.org/netty 
Grizzly是Sun的GlassFish服务器的底层NIO框架：http://grizzly.java.net 

注：以下数据为开发环境简单测试，存在较大统计误差，并且Mina采用的是旧版本(因新版本API不兼容)，可能存在测试的不公平性。 

测试版本： 
Grizzly2.1.1，Netty3.2.2，Mina1.1.7 

测试结论： 
服务器Linux下TPS，Netty最高，但波动非常大，Grizzly次之，但波动小，Mina最低。 
本机Windows下TPS，Grizzly最高，Mina次之，Netty最低。 

测试结果： 
单一长连接，100并发，来回数据均为1K： 
服务器Linux下TPS，Grizzly：15061，Netty：15211，Mina: 14828。 
本机Windows下TPS，Grizzly：6945，Netty：4433，Mina：5750。 

测试详细： 

1. Linux: 

(1) Grizzly: 
Java代码  收藏代码
  1. [01:48:17] count: 72059, error: 0,tps:16046  
  2. [01:48:19] count: 103081, error: 0,tps:15412  
  3. [01:48:21] count: 133459, error: 0,tps:15169  
  4. [01:48:23] count: 164335, error: 0,tps:15436  
  5. [01:48:25] count: 195370, error: 0,tps:15516  
  6. [01:48:27] count: 226222, error: 0,tps:15425  
  7. [01:48:29] count: 256864, error: 0,tps:15320  
  8. [01:48:31] count: 287435, error: 0,tps:15284  
  9. [01:48:33] count: 317908, error: 0,tps:15235  
  10. [01:48:35] count: 348632, error: 0,tps:15361  
  11. [01:48:37] count: 379702, error: 0,tps:15534  
  12. [01:48:39] count: 410473, error: 0,tps:15384  
  13. [01:48:41] count: 441696, error: 0,tps:15610  
  14. [01:48:43] count: 472648, error: 0,tps:15474  
  15. [01:48:45] count: 503532, error: 0,tps:15440  
  16. [01:48:47] count: 534368, error: 0,tps:15417  
  17. [01:48:49] count: 565526, error: 0,tps:15578  
  18. [01:48:51] count: 596600, error: 0,tps:15536  
  19. [01:48:53] count: 627111, error: 0,tps:15254  
  20. [01:48:55] count: 657956, error: 0,tps:15422  
  21. [01:48:57] count: 689197, error: 0,tps:15619  
  22. [01:48:59] count: 719944, error: 0,tps:15372  
  23. [01:49:01] count: 750797, error: 0,tps:15426  
  24. [01:49:03] count: 781439, error: 0,tps:15321  
  25. [01:49:05] count: 812245, error: 0,tps:15401  
  26. [01:49:07] count: 842992, error: 0,tps:15372  
  27. [01:49:09] count: 873677, error: 0,tps:15341  
  28. [01:49:11] count: 904656, error: 0,tps:15488  
  29. [01:49:13] count: 935273, error: 0,tps:15307  
  30. [01:49:15] count: 965723, error: 0,tps:15224  
  31. [01:49:17] count: 996358, error: 0,tps:15316  
  32. +================================================================+  
  33. |             Dubbo Remoting Performance Test Report             |  
  34. +================================================================+  
  35. |                        Test Environment                        |  
  36. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  37. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  38. | Client OS: Linux 2.6.18-128.el5xen amd64                       |  
  39. | Client CPU: 16 cores                                           |  
  40. | Client JVM: Java HotSpot(TM) 64-Bit Server VM 1.6.0_18-b07     |  
  41. | Client Memory: 535,953,408 bytes (Max: 535,953,408 bytes)      |  
  42. | Client Network: eth0                                           |  
  43. | Client MTU: 1500 bytes                                         |  
  44. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  45. |                           Test Scene                           |  
  46. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  47. | Client Transporter: grizzly                                    |  
  48. | Serialization: hessian2                                        |  
  49. | Response Timeout: 5000 ms                                      |  
  50. | Data Length: 1024 bytes                                        |  
  51. | Client Shared Connections: 1                                   |  
  52. | Client Concurrent Threads: 100                                 |  
  53. | Run Times Per Thread: 10000                                    |  
  54. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  55. |                          Test Result                           |  
  56. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  57. | Succeeded Requests: 1,000,000                                  |  
  58. | Failed Requests: 0                                             |  
  59. | Client Elapsed Time: 3404 ms                                   |  
  60. | Average Response Time: 6 ms                                    |  
  61. | Requests Per Second: 15061/s                                   |  
  62. | Throughput Per Second: 30,846,411 bytes/s                      |  
  63. +================================================================+  


(2) Netty: 
Java代码  收藏代码
  1. [01:53:56] count: 113330, error: 0,tps:17381  
  2. [01:53:58] count: 136859, error: 0,tps:11764  
  3. [01:54:00] count: 160062, error: 0,tps:11601  
  4. [01:54:02] count: 186185, error: 0,tps:13060  
  5. [01:54:04] count: 209548, error: 0,tps:11681  
  6. [01:54:06] count: 236865, error: 0,tps:13658  
  7. [01:54:08] count: 263920, error: 0,tps:13526  
  8. [01:54:10] count: 288269, error: 0,tps:12174  
  9. [01:54:12] count: 312995, error: 0,tps:12362  
  10. [01:54:14] count: 336914, error: 0,tps:11958  
  11. [01:54:16] count: 362085, error: 0,tps:12584  
  12. [01:54:18] count: 385552, error: 0,tps:11732  
  13. [01:54:20] count: 409792, error: 0,tps:12119  
  14. [01:54:22] count: 442461, error: 0,tps:16334  
  15. [01:54:24] count: 469138, error: 0,tps:13338  
  16. [01:54:26] count: 493428, error: 0,tps:12144  
  17. [01:54:28] count: 521258, error: 0,tps:13915  
  18. [01:54:30] count: 560968, error: 0,tps:19854  
  19. [01:54:32] count: 609262, error: 0,tps:24146  
  20. [01:54:34] count: 657769, error: 0,tps:24250  
  21. [01:54:36] count: 704225, error: 0,tps:23226  
  22. [01:54:38] count: 736721, error: 0,tps:16248  
  23. [01:54:40] count: 771944, error: 0,tps:17611  
  24. [01:54:42] count: 808276, error: 0,tps:18164  
  25. [01:54:44] count: 840891, error: 0,tps:16307  
  26. [01:54:46] count: 873613, error: 0,tps:16360  
  27. [01:54:48] count: 911968, error: 0,tps:19174  
  28. [01:54:50] count: 960476, error: 0,tps:24248  
  29. +================================================================+  
  30. |             Dubbo Remoting Performance Test Report             |  
  31. +================================================================+  
  32. |                        Test Environment                        |  
  33. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  34. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  35. | Client OS: Linux 2.6.18-128.el5xen amd64                       |  
  36. | Client CPU: 16 cores                                           |  
  37. | Client JVM: Java HotSpot(TM) 64-Bit Server VM 1.6.0_18-b07     |  
  38. | Client Memory: 536,215,552 bytes (Max: 536,215,552 bytes)      |  
  39. | Client Network: eth0                                           |  
  40. | Client MTU: 1500 bytes                                         |  
  41. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  42. |                           Test Scene                           |  
  43. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  44. | Client Transporter: netty                                      |  
  45. | Serialization: hessian2                                        |  
  46. | Response Timeout: 5000 ms                                      |  
  47. | Data Length: 1024 bytes                                        |  
  48. | Client Shared Connections: 1                                   |  
  49. | Client Concurrent Threads: 100                                 |  
  50. | Run Times Per Thread: 10000                                    |  
  51. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  52. |                          Test Result                           |  
  53. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  54. | Succeeded Requests: 1,000,000                                  |  
  55. | Failed Requests: 0                                             |  
  56. | Client Elapsed Time: 3151 ms                                   |  
  57. | Average Response Time: 6 ms                                    |  
  58. | Requests Per Second: 15211/s                                   |  
  59. | Throughput Per Second: 31,152,738 bytes/s                      |  
  60. +================================================================+  


(3) Mina: 
Java代码  收藏代码
  1. [01:56:39] count: 103543, error: 0,tps:14427  
  2. [01:56:41] count: 132855, error: 0,tps:14655  
  3. [01:56:43] count: 166918, error: 0,tps:17021  
  4. [01:56:45] count: 195301, error: 0,tps:14190  
  5. [01:56:47] count: 224616, error: 0,tps:14657  
  6. [01:56:49] count: 262498, error: 0,tps:18941  
  7. [01:56:51] count: 294846, error: 0,tps:16174  
  8. [01:56:53] count: 334369, error: 0,tps:19761  
  9. [01:56:55] count: 353994, error: 0,tps:9812  
  10. [01:56:57] count: 379195, error: 0,tps:12596  
  11. [01:56:59] count: 423003, error: 0,tps:21886  
  12. [01:57:01] count: 466447, error: 0,tps:21721  
  13. [01:57:03] count: 496609, error: 0,tps:15081  
  14. [01:57:05] count: 514800, error: 0,tps:9095  
  15. [01:57:07] count: 539324, error: 0,tps:12262  
  16. [01:57:09] count: 571361, error: 0,tps:16018  
  17. [01:57:11] count: 594834, error: 0,tps:11736  
  18. [01:57:13] count: 616056, error: 0,tps:10611  
  19. [01:57:15] count: 643891, error: 0,tps:13917  
  20. [01:57:17] count: 662115, error: 0,tps:9111  
  21. [01:57:19] count: 688659, error: 0,tps:13271  
  22. [01:57:21] count: 724968, error: 0,tps:18154  
  23. [01:57:23] count: 767680, error: 0,tps:21356  
  24. [01:57:25] count: 802471, error: 0,tps:17395  
  25. [01:57:27] count: 842291, error: 0,tps:19910  
  26. [01:57:29] count: 877187, error: 0,tps:17448  
  27. [01:57:31] count: 917275, error: 0,tps:20044  
  28. [01:57:33] count: 945382, error: 0,tps:14053  
  29. [01:57:35] count: 972663, error: 0,tps:13637  
  30. +================================================================+  
  31. |             Dubbo Remoting Performance Test Report             |  
  32. +================================================================+  
  33. |                        Test Environment                        |  
  34. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  35. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  36. | Client OS: Linux 2.6.18-128.el5xen amd64                       |  
  37. | Client CPU: 16 cores                                           |  
  38. | Client JVM: Java HotSpot(TM) 64-Bit Server VM 1.6.0_18-b07     |  
  39. | Client Memory: 536,150,016 bytes (Max: 536,150,016 bytes)      |  
  40. | Client Network: eth0                                           |  
  41. | Client MTU: 1500 bytes                                         |  
  42. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  43. |                           Test Scene                           |  
  44. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  45. | Client Transporter: mina                                       |  
  46. | Serialization: hessian2                                        |  
  47. | Response Timeout: 5000 ms                                      |  
  48. | Data Length: 1024 bytes                                        |  
  49. | Client Shared Connections: 1                                   |  
  50. | Client Concurrent Threads: 100                                 |  
  51. | Run Times Per Thread: 10000                                    |  
  52. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  53. |                          Test Result                           |  
  54. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  55. | Succeeded Requests: 1,000,000                                  |  
  56. | Failed Requests: 0                                             |  
  57. | Client Elapsed Time: 3207 ms                                   |  
  58. | Average Response Time: 6 ms                                    |  
  59. | Requests Per Second: 14828/s                                   |  
  60. | Throughput Per Second: 30,368,031 bytes/s                      |  
  61. +================================================================+  


2. Windows: 

(1) Grizzly: 
Java代码  收藏代码
  1. +================================================================+  
  2. |             Dubbo Remoting Performance Test Report             |  
  3. +================================================================+  
  4. |                        Test Environment                        |  
  5. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  6. | Server OS: Windows XP 5.1 x86                                  |  
  7. | Server CPU: 2 cores                                            |  
  8. | Server JVM: Java HotSpot(TM) Client VM 1.6.0_18-b07            |  
  9. | Server Memory: 16,252,928 bytes (Max: 259,522,560 bytes)       |  
  10. | Server Network: Intel(R) WiFi Link 5100 AGN - Teefer2 Miniport |  
  11. | Server MTU: 1500 bytes                                         |  
  12. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  13. | Client OS: Windows XP 5.1 x86                                  |  
  14. | Client CPU: 2 cores                                            |  
  15. | Client JVM: Java HotSpot(TM) Client VM 1.6.0_18-b07            |  
  16. | Client Memory: 16,515,072 bytes (Max: 259,522,560 bytes)       |  
  17. | Client Network: Intel(R) WiFi Link 5100 AGN - Teefer2 Miniport |  
  18. | Client MTU: 1500 bytes                                         |  
  19. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  20. |                           Test Scene                           |  
  21. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  22. | Server Transporter: grizzly                                    |  
  23. | Server Service Threads: 100                                    |  
  24. | Client Transporter: grizzly                                    |  
  25. | Serialization: hessian2                                        |  
  26. | Response Timeout: 5000 ms                                      |  
  27. | Data Length: 1024 bytes                                        |  
  28. | Client Shared Connections: 1                                   |  
  29. | Client Concurrent Threads: 100                                 |  
  30. | Run Times Per Thread: 10000                                    |  
  31. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  32. |                          Test Result                           |  
  33. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  34. | Succeeded Requests: 1,000,000                                  |  
  35. | Failed Requests: 0                                             |  
  36. | Client Elapsed Time: 14393 ms                                  |  
  37. | Average Response Time: 14 ms                                   |  
  38. | Requests Per Second: 6945/s                                    |  
  39. | Throughput Per Second: 14,224,879 bytes/s                      |  
  40. +================================================================+  


(2) Netty: 
Java代码  收藏代码
  1. +================================================================+  
  2. |             Dubbo Remoting Performance Test Report             |  
  3. +================================================================+  
  4. |                        Test Environment                        |  
  5. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  6. | Server OS: Windows XP 5.1 x86                                  |  
  7. | Server CPU: 2 cores                                            |  
  8. | Server JVM: Java HotSpot(TM) Client VM 1.6.0_18-b07            |  
  9. | Server Memory: 16,252,928 bytes (Max: 259,522,560 bytes)       |  
  10. | Server Network: Intel(R) WiFi Link 5100 AGN - Teefer2 Miniport |  
  11. | Server MTU: 1500 bytes                                         |  
  12. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  13. | Client OS: Windows XP 5.1 x86                                  |  
  14. | Client CPU: 2 cores                                            |  
  15. | Client JVM: Java HotSpot(TM) Client VM 1.6.0_18-b07            |  
  16. | Client Memory: 16,646,144 bytes (Max: 259,522,560 bytes)       |  
  17. | Client Network: Intel(R) WiFi Link 5100 AGN - Teefer2 Miniport |  
  18. | Client MTU: 1500 bytes                                         |  
  19. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  20. |                           Test Scene                           |  
  21. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  22. | Server Transporter: netty                                      |  
  23. | Server Service Threads: 100                                    |  
  24. | Client Transporter: netty                                      |  
  25. | Serialization: hessian2                                        |  
  26. | Response Timeout: 5000 ms                                      |  
  27. | Data Length: 1024 bytes                                        |  
  28. | Client Shared Connections: 1                                   |  
  29. | Client Concurrent Threads: 100                                 |  
  30. | Run Times Per Thread: 10000                                    |  
  31. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  32. |                          Test Result                           |  
  33. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  34. | Succeeded Requests: 999,988                                    |  
  35. | Failed Requests: 12                                            |  
  36. | Client Elapsed Time: 34434 ms                                  |  
  37. | Average Response Time: 22 ms                                   |  
  38. | Requests Per Second: 4422/s                                    |  
  39. | Throughput Per Second: 9,057,411 bytes/s                       |  
  40. +================================================================+  


(3) Mina: 
Java代码  收藏代码
  1. +================================================================+  
  2. |             Dubbo Remoting Performance Test Report             |  
  3. +================================================================+  
  4. |                        Test Environment                        |  
  5. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  6. | Server OS: Windows XP 5.1 x86                                  |  
  7. | Server CPU: 2 cores                                            |  
  8. | Server JVM: Java HotSpot(TM) Client VM 1.6.0_18-b07            |  
  9. | Server Memory: 16,252,928 bytes (Max: 259,522,560 bytes)       |  
  10. | Server Network: Intel(R) WiFi Link 5100 AGN - Teefer2 Miniport |  
  11. | Server MTU: 1500 bytes                                         |  
  12. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  13. | Client OS: Windows XP 5.1 x86                                  |  
  14. | Client CPU: 2 cores                                            |  
  15. | Client JVM: Java HotSpot(TM) Client VM 1.6.0_18-b07            |  
  16. | Client Memory: 16,646,144 bytes (Max: 259,522,560 bytes)       |  
  17. | Client Network: Intel(R) WiFi Link 5100 AGN - Teefer2 Miniport |  
  18. | Client MTU: 1500 bytes                                         |  
  19. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  20. |                           Test Scene                           |  
  21. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  22. | Server Transporter: mina                                       |  
  23. | Server Service Threads: 100                                    |  
  24. | Client Transporter: mina                                       |  
  25. | Serialization: hessian2                                        |  
  26. | Response Timeout: 5000 ms                                      |  
  27. | Data Length: 1024 bytes                                        |  
  28. | Client Shared Connections: 1                                   |  
  29. | Client Concurrent Threads: 100                                 |  
  30. | Run Times Per Thread: 10000                                    |  
  31. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  32. |                          Test Result                           |  
  33. +----------------------------------------------------------------+  
  34. | Succeeded Requests: 1,000,000                                  |  
  35. | Failed Requests: 0                                             |  
  36. | Client Elapsed Time: 6473 ms                                   |  
  37. | Average Response Time: 17 ms                                   |  
  38. | Requests Per Second: 5750/s                                    |  
  39. | Throughput Per Second: 11,777,750 bytes/s                      |  
  40. +================================================================+  
0 0
电子音乐软件下载 电子音乐软件下载
原创粉丝点击
热门IT博客
手机扫描扑克牌软件手机扫描扑克牌软件
二战德国火箭炮数据二战德国火箭炮数据
办公软件2003官方
永恒之塔5.2捏脸数据
sql server 2000 cdkey
电脑端口查询
乐乎青年公寓北京城乡
广东普宁淘宝裤子厂
免费的域名
java单例模式应用场景
只有我知bilibili电影
数据库营销ppt
淘宝新店访客怎么提升
网络usb服务器
ic layout软件
淘宝商品详情页设计
天津达德网络
孤独啊网络歌手
mac appstore更换账号
淘宝保证金怎么解冻
热门问题 老师的惩罚 人脸识别 我在镇武司摸鱼那些年 重生之率土为王 我在大康的咸鱼生活 盘龙之生命进化 天生仙种 凡人之先天五行 春回大明朝 姑娘不必设防，我是瞎子 八角和茴香的区别 八角价格 八角游乐园好玩吗 八角游乐园门票多少钱 八角游乐园门票 野生八角 八角游乐园门票价格 八角刺 八角游乐园门票团购 八角游乐园多少钱 水八角 八角梅 八角油 八角香 八角尖尖 八角游乐园在哪里 八角叶 八角椅 八角亭制作 怀孕可以吃八角吗 八角游乐园站 八角钉 八角窗 八角木 八角连 八角辫 八角怪 八角台 毒八角 八角游乐园怎么样 八角的功效 八角作用 八角停 八角游乐园怎么走 八角井 八角刺树 八角图 八角盒价格 八角实验台 八角游乐园票价 八角的作用

程序博客网，程序员的互联网技术博客家园。csdn论坛精品 msdn技术资料都在这里